A subtle thing done by the author of this piece was the earth in the background. Initially, it appears to be there to add perspective to the drawing. Upon further inspection, you can see that the planet is centered on North America. This creates subliminal messages, causing one to believe that America is the center of power, without them realizing it or.
This blog will explore the rhetorical appeals present in two pieces of propaganda from the 1960s Space Race from both the American and Soviet perspective.
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
America's Appeal to Logic
The propaganda put out by Americans in the 1960's came in various forms. It used different methods and appeals to get its message across. This piece in particular, depicting Americans armed with machine guns crushing a Soviet flag and helmet while planting an American flag on the moon, is a mouthful to describe and can appeal to ones logic, or logos. The poster calls for America to "Clean the Communist Filth off the Moon." The astronauts are powerfully depicted and are almost intimidating in nature. It's almost as if they're trying to scare you into joining the space race to help America. What's the logical decision when three heavily armed men ask you to do something? Exactly! You do what they say. This is in stark contrast to that of the Soviet poster, which encourages kids to use their imagination and become the next generation of astronauts.
The American astronauts are also planting a large American flag on the moon, claiming it as their own. It's human nature to defend what's ours so the logical thing to do in this situation would be "clean" the Soviets off the moon. Also, since the American flag is much larger than the tattered Soviet one, it leads the audience(Americans) to believe that America is the more powerful nation and that in order to succeed, you must follow them. Otherwise you run the risk of being crushed by a burly astronaut.
A subtle thing done by the author of this piece was the earth in the background. Initially, it appears to be there to add perspective to the drawing. Upon further inspection, you can see that the planet is centered on North America. This creates subliminal messages, causing one to believe that America is the center of power, without them realizing it or.
A subtle thing done by the author of this piece was the earth in the background. Initially, it appears to be there to add perspective to the drawing. Upon further inspection, you can see that the planet is centered on North America. This creates subliminal messages, causing one to believe that America is the center of power, without them realizing it or.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
An interesting post, one that examines logos in a way I hadn't considered.
ReplyDeleteThat said, there are some points I feel should be addressed. For instance: what makes Russia's presence "Communist Filth?" Granted, if this is intended for an audience that already is against Communism, perhaps this was to go without saying.
In addition, appealing to an audience's logos implies a use of facts, which seem to be absent from this poster. No one had reached the moon at this time, and even then, the inherent danger in bringing a rifle to space was obvious.
Overall, this is a very interesting analysis, and you are able to point out some uses of logic I don't think most people would have seen, but some parts of it just don't make any sense.
-Jesse
At first glace I really wasn't sure I could make any logic in this poster. I mean how can you find logic in a group of Americans with guns standing on the moon. It doesn't seem logical all. But I think by reading more into it and looking at smaller parts of the poster it really does have some logic in it, maybe not the most clear logic but still some.
ReplyDelete